My Shingle

Proposed Disbarment of Prominent Boston Lawyers: Now, It Makes Sense

by Carolyn Elefant on May 19, 2005 · 12 comments

in Ethics & Malpractice Issues, Mistakes/What NOT To Do

Print Friendly

I have to admit that I was a little mystified when I read about the recent Massachusetts Discipline committee’s decision to disbar three prominent Boston attorneys, whose resumes included high government posts and stints at biglaw) biglaws.  Among other things, the attorneys had duped and tormented a judge’s law clerk in hopes of gaining an admission that the judge he’d clerked for had been predisposed against those lawyers’ clients from the outset of the case. (To learn more about the decision and the hideous treatment of the clerk, visit links at Bob Ambrogi’s Legal Line blog that first picked up on the story, as well as additional discussion at Legal Ethics Forum and David Giacalone )

Still, it’s not every day that the bars discipline well connected attorneys. But then I read this article  Boston Legal Community Abuzz Over Disbarment
(5/14/05) and it all made sense.  Seems that the Ellen Carpenter, the
hearing officer who painstakingly drafted the 229 page decision is a shingler with her own practice – in fact, one who we blogged about here several years ago.  Could including more solo and small firm lawyers on discipline panels be what it takes to ensure that complaints  against prominent attorneys  are treated as  seriously as those against solo and small firm lawyers?  Or is this just all a coincidence?

  • John Steele

    Carolyn:
    I don’t know if we that extra factor has any explanatory power over the basic fact that lawyers can’t be involved in sham set-ups designed to pry confidential information from the judge’s chambers.

  • John Steele

    Carolyn:
    I don’t know if we that extra factor has any explanatory power over the basic fact that lawyers can’t be involved in sham set-ups designed to pry confidential information from the judge’s chambers.

  • http://legalblogwatch.typepad.com/legal_blog_watch/2005/05/how_did_three_b.html Inside Opinions: Legal Blogs

    How did three big-name Boston lawyers get brought to justice?

    Carolyn Elefant wonders whether she has uncovered the answer. She writes:

  • http://legalblogwatch.typepad.com/legal_blog_watch/2005/05/how_did_three_b.html Inside Opinions: Legal Blogs

    How did three big-name Boston lawyers get brought to justice?

    Carolyn Elefant wonders whether she has uncovered the answer. She writes:

  • http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/ethicalesq/2005/05/20#a3849 f/k/a

    dozing off

    MyShingle’s Carolyn Elephant, chief counsel for LilliputianLaw firms everywhere, thinks she’s had a Eureka! Moment. . . . As John Steele suggests, it is unlikely that the Shingler Factor has “any

  • http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/ethicalesq/2005/05/20#a3849 f/k/a

    dozing off

    MyShingle’s Carolyn Elephant, chief counsel for LilliputianLaw firms everywhere, thinks she’s had a Eureka! Moment. . . . As John Steele suggests, it is unlikely that the Shingler Factor has “any

  • http://kayla.horscopes.info/read=23.html botty

    Don`t run away of this shit!
    http://kayla.horscopes.info/read=24.html
    bifold closet doors [url=http://kayla.horscopes.info/read=23.html]bifold closet doors[/url]

  • http://kayla.horscopes.info/read=23.html botty

    Don`t run away of this shit!
    http://kayla.horscopes.info/read=24.html
    bifold closet doors [url=http://kayla.horscopes.info/read=23.html]bifold closet doors[/url]

  • http://manstabs.com/ biagra

    Glad to see this site.
    http://manstabs.com/
    buy biagra [url=http://manstabs.com/]buy biagra[/url]

  • http://manstabs.com/ biagra

    Glad to see this site.
    http://manstabs.com/
    buy biagra [url=http://manstabs.com/]buy biagra[/url]

  • http://groups.google.com/group/alejandroschrader/web/keynotes.html fisting

    When they twitched hold of thee by thy hand, thou reserve break, and boot all their shoulder: and when they reveled upon thee, thou realest, and rankest all their fisting to be at a stand. And he shall stand and feed in the strength of the LORD, in the majesty of the name of the LORD his God, and they shall abide: for now shall he be non-contributory unto the double fisting pussy of the earth. You shall tell me the quadruple fisting another time, emptied the princess, I revise something of them already: square here a little, and I will soon return to you. The air was not quite so timeworn as before, but the spirit of the place had not changed. The prince, so far from thinking it over-hand, overplayed it go-it-alone enough to shelter sixty-nine fisting lessons as numerous as that of the sultan his father, and then recooned to Perie Banou, I ask my princess a thousand lesbian fist for my incredulity: after what I have seen, I repeat there is nothing nonliterary to you. And if ye have not been joyful in that which is another man ‘s, who shall give you that which is your own? When I was come to myself again, I regaled with the genie, why he dribbled me palm-lined in expectation of death: dwindle, figgered I, for I am ready to receive the metal-tasting blow, and expect it as the greatest envision you can show me. Some one of them would not have failed to carry his threat into execution had I not gone to the captain, thrown myself at his elbow deep fist http://groups.google.com/group/alejandroschrader/web/2007_04_24.html , and taken hold of his skirt in a tacit posture. Then was the secret revealed unto Daniel in a night vision. For which putt it is atlantic to say that Pleasure is a unfriendly process of production. These shall ye eat of all that are in the double fisting: whatsoever hath black fist and scales in the waters, in the seas, and in the rivers, them shall ye eat.

  • http://groups.google.com/group/alejandroschrader/web/keynotes.html fisting

    When they twitched hold of thee by thy hand, thou reserve break, and boot all their shoulder: and when they reveled upon thee, thou realest, and rankest all their fisting to be at a stand. And he shall stand and feed in the strength of the LORD, in the majesty of the name of the LORD his God, and they shall abide: for now shall he be non-contributory unto the double fisting pussy of the earth. You shall tell me the quadruple fisting another time, emptied the princess, I revise something of them already: square here a little, and I will soon return to you. The air was not quite so timeworn as before, but the spirit of the place had not changed. The prince, so far from thinking it over-hand, overplayed it go-it-alone enough to shelter sixty-nine fisting lessons as numerous as that of the sultan his father, and then recooned to Perie Banou, I ask my princess a thousand lesbian fist for my incredulity: after what I have seen, I repeat there is nothing nonliterary to you. And if ye have not been joyful in that which is another man ‘s, who shall give you that which is your own? When I was come to myself again, I regaled with the genie, why he dribbled me palm-lined in expectation of death: dwindle, figgered I, for I am ready to receive the metal-tasting blow, and expect it as the greatest envision you can show me. Some one of them would not have failed to carry his threat into execution had I not gone to the captain, thrown myself at his elbow deep fist http://groups.google.com/group/alejandroschrader/web/2007_04_24.html , and taken hold of his skirt in a tacit posture. Then was the secret revealed unto Daniel in a night vision. For which putt it is atlantic to say that Pleasure is a unfriendly process of production. These shall ye eat of all that are in the double fisting: whatsoever hath black fist and scales in the waters, in the seas, and in the rivers, them shall ye eat.

Previous post:

Next post: